PP: Sigma 50-120mm f/2.8 DC OS Review – Frighteningly Sharp

Sigma 50-120mm f/2.8 DC OS:
B&H Photo / Amazon / Adorama

PetaPixel has published a full hands-on review of the new Samyang AF 60-180mm f/2.8—also marketed as Rokinon in North America and co-developed in collaboration with Schneider-Kreuznach. Priced at $1,099 and earning a 7/10 PetaPixel Score, the lens officially completes Samyang’s lightweight full-frame f/2.8 zoom trinity for Sony E-mount and L-mount.

Tested on a Sony a7R V in chilly fall weather in Calgary, here is every detail from the review broken down by section.

Completing the Samyang f/2.8 Trinity

  • Third-Party Competition Context: Japanese third-party makers Tamron (with its G2 series) and Sigma already offer complete full-frame professional f/2.8 zoom trinities, while Chinese manufacturers are only just entering the autofocus zoom market.
  • Samyang’s Lineup: Korean manufacturer Samyang moved quickly and quietly to finish its own full-frame f/2.8 trinity, pairing this new 60-180mm f/2.8 with the existing Samyang AF 14-24mm f/2.8 and Samyang AF 24-60mm f/2.8.
  • Rebranding Note: Samyang lenses are sold under the Rokinon brand name in North America—they are the exact same optics.

Design, Build Quality, and Controls

  • Weight & Chassis: Weighs just 730g, making it slightly lighter than the Tamron 70-180mm f/2.8 and substantially lighter than the Sigma 70-200mm f/2.8 Sport. While lightweight, the barrel itself still has a fairly bulky front profile.
  • Plastics & Tactile Feel: Relies heavily on plastic construction. While long-time Rokinon users report years of reliable operation, the lens feels less refined, somewhat flimsy, and a bit “cheap” / down-market in the hand compared to rivals.
  • Hood & Filters: Features a 77mm front filter thread (deemed appropriate for this class) and includes a basic plastic petal-shaped lens hood that locks solidly onto the bayonet mount with a bit of coercion.
  • Dual-Texture Rings: Uses different rubber textures on the manual focus ring and zoom ring. Though visually slightly distracting, it allows you to distinguish between the two rings purely by touch without taking your eye off the viewfinder.
  • Ring Feel: The manual focus ring turns very smoothly with good resistance. The zoom ring is smooth once moving, but suffers from noticeable initial startup inertia/stiffness that feels a little rough until you get used to it.
  • Buttons & Switches: Includes an AF/MF selector switch, a customizable button (which works fine but feels unrefined and makes a loud, clicky noise when pressed), and a zoom lock switch.
  • Zoom Lock & Extension: The zoom lock holds the lens at 60mm to prevent creep—you cannot force past it and must physically unlock it before zooming. When zoomed to 180mm, the barrel extension is short/minimal and barely alters the center of balance.
  • Missing Aperture Ring: There is no physical aperture ring on the lens (typical for this price tier, though notable if you prefer manual aperture controls).
  • Weather Sealing: Built with internal baffles and rubber gasketing around the lens mount for ruggedness across varied shooting environments.

Autofocus, Stabilization, and Teleconverter Support

  • No Optical Image Stabilization (OIS): Unlike both the Tamron and Sigma alternatives, the Samyang 60-180mm f/2.8 has no built-in optical stabilizer. This helps shave weight and keep cost down, but makes you reliant on camera IBIS (like on the Sony a7R V)—and even with IBIS, OIS is missed at 180mm or on non-stabilized bodies.
  • Stepping Motor (STM) Autofocus: Uses a basic stepping motor rather than an advanced linear motor or voice coil motor (VCM). Focusing is quiet, smooth, and accurate, but noticeably slower when racking from near to far—making it disappointing for fast sports or action photography.
  • No Teleconverter Support: Like the Tamron 70-180mm, it does not accept teleconverters (the Sigma 70-200mm f/2.8 Sport is required if you need teleconverter compatibility).

Close-Up Performance

  • Not a True Macro, Still Useful: While 60-180mm and 70-200mm zooms aren’t macro lenses, this lens can handle close-up portraits and event detail shots.
  • Maximum Magnification: Achieves a respectable 1:4 (0.26x) life-size reproduction ratio, hitting its best close-focusing performance at 80mm. Stopping down slightly boosts sharpness for detail shots.

Optical Performance: Sharpness, Bokeh, Flare, and LoCA

  • Sharpness (Standout Strength): Samyang “killed it” on sharpness—performance is impressive wide open across the entire zoom range:
    • At 180mm: Center sharpness and contrast are already very strong wide open at f/2.8 (improving slightly stopped down). Corner sharpness at f/2.8 is surprisingly good with low vignetting—actually outperforming the Sigma 70-200mm f/2.8 Sport and giving the Tamron a strong run for its money.
    • At 60mm: Center sharpness at f/2.8 is slightly softer than at 180mm, though still very good and fully usable wide open (getting even sharper stopped down). Corners are also strong at f/2.8 with potentially less vignetting than the Tamron.
  • Bokeh & Specular Highlights:
    • Background Rendering: Overall out-of-focus rendering is smooth and pleasant with natural transitions and no harshness—great for portraits and shallow depth-of-field work.
    • Specular Highlights: Uses a 9-bladed aperture. Wide open at f/2.8, highlight interiors are clean with minimal onion rings and no halo effect, though highlights show noticeable cat’s-eye truncation near the extreme edges of the frame. Stopping down restores nice, round highlights.
  • Flare Control: Tested directly against a harsh COB light. Unlike Samyang’s 14-24mm (which showed vivid rainbow ghosting), the 60-180mm wide open at f/2.8 avoids ugly ghosting and instead shows mild green ghosting with a fair amount of veiled flare (hazy contrast loss). Stopping down enlarges the green ghosting/color field somewhat, though overall flare performance is average/decent for real-world use and the hood blocks stray light well.
  • LoCA (Longitudinal Chromatic Aberration): Shows slight green/magenta color fringing in out-of-focus areas at f/2.8 on test charts, but it is minimal, unlikely to bother most real-world photos, and clears up quickly when stopped down.

Sony E-Mount vs. L-Mount: Should You Buy It?

  • For Sony E-Mount Shooters (Harder to Recommend): In E-mount, the Samyang goes head-to-head with the Tamron 70-180mm f/2.8 Di III VC VXD G2 at essentially the same $1,099 price and weight. Because the Tamron G2 is even more compact, feels slightly better built, has a noticeably faster autofocus motor, and includes optical stabilization (VC), Chris recommends the Tamron over the Samyang as the better overall value on Sony E-mount—and notes Tamron effectively covers the whole f/2.8 trinity better on E-mount as well.
  • When It Makes Sense on Sony E-Mount: Only worth choosing over the Tamron if you specifically prioritize maximum corner-to-corner sharpness at 180mm, slightly lower weight on an IBIS-equipped Sony body, or want the wider 60mm starting focal length.
  • For L-Mount Shooters (Much Stronger Pick): Because Tamron isn’t available on L-mount, the Samyang 60-180mm f/2.8 only competes against the much larger, heavier, and far more expensive Sigma 70-200mm f/2.8 Sport and Panasonic Lumix S 70-200mm f/2.8. On L-mount, both this lens and the full Samyang f/2.8 trinity make a lot of sense for shooters with IBIS bodies who want strong optics at lower size, weight, and cost.
  • Final Verdict (7/10): Despite a plasticky feel, slower STM autofocus, and lack of OIS or an aperture ring, the Samyang AF 60-180mm f/2.8 is “frighteningly sharp” and delivers strong optical performance for the money.

Follow SonyAddict on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and YouTube

Plus our owners’ groups
Sony a1 Owners Group
Sony a9 Owners Group
Sony a7 Owners Group

This entry was posted in 3rd Party Lens and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Trackbacks are closed, but you can post a comment.
  • FCC disclosure statement: this post may contain affiliate links or promotions that do not cost readers anything but help keep this website alive. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Thanks for your support!